We were seated by a smiling young girl and discovered that most of the tables are for a party of four and had to bring over another chair. This not being our first time in this situation it really wasn’t a problem. I then noticed that the options were party of four or much larger and we didn’t fit into either category. Our menus were handed out and I found myself grinning at the homemade, home printed folded menus. The choices were limited and some of the options were contradictions with each other. Like a twelve piece fried shrimp for $11.99 or a twelve piece Seafood plate (Which is either Shrimp, Catfish or ‘chicken’) for $12.99. Hmmmmm…..????
The last time I checked ‘Chicken’ DID NOT qualify as seafood!
We made our orders of Shrimp plates, seafood plates, and burgers. Three of which came with “salads”. The salads contained of only lettuce and tomato and nothing else. Our main dished arrived and my son loved his burger, my husband loved his hamburger steak and my daughters and I hated our Shrimp plates. The Shrimp were obviously previously frozen and the breading to greasy and over cooked. The catfish was overly salty and the french-fries not salty enough.
There isn’t really much else to say about this place. Pretty basic menu, pretty basic atmosphere, and pretty basic food. This place may become something in the future, but they would have to seriously step it up a notch to keep in the running with another restaurant just few more miles down the interstate that offers all this place offers and more and with much better quality. This will not be one of my go to spots and I doubt I could ever be talked into returning again. I hope that they do well because obviously it is someone’s dream to run a restaurant, but the quality and service are more of a nightmare.
**UPDATE**
Unfortunately this place has since closed down. I truly hope that whoever started I-40 Catfish does not give up on their dreams. Another restaurant was opened in the same location since I-40 Catfish closed down and has also closed. Location and parking also seem to be a huge issue with this building.